From Ars Technica:
On Friday, the online art community DeviantArt announced DreamUp, an AI-powered text-to-image generator service powered by Stable Diffusion. Simultaneously, DeviantArt launched an initiative that ostensibly lets artists opt out of AI image training but also made everyone’s art opt in by default, which angered many members.
DreamUp creates novel AI-generated art based on text prompts. Due to its Stable Diffusion roots, DreamUp learned how to generate images by analyzing hundreds of millions of images scraped off sites like DeviantArt and collected into LAION datasets without artists’ permission, a potential irony that some DeviantArt members find problematic.
As we’ve reported frequently on Ars in the past, Stable Diffusion’s web-scraping nature ignited a huge debate earlier this year among artists that challenge the ethics of AI-generated artwork. Some art communities have taken hard stances against any AI-generated images, banning them completely.
Perhaps anticipating a backlash, DeviantArt is making overtures to pacify artists who might be upset about their work being used to train AI image generators. The site is providing a special “noai” flag that artists can check in their image settings to opt out of third-party image datasets. (Whether third-party image scrapers will honor this flag, however, remains to be seen.)
. . . .
Also, DeviantArt will let artists opt out of letting their images train DreamUp in the future, but each artist must fill out a form that requires human review first. This policy has led to significant pushback among DeviantArt members, some of whom have threatened to delete all of their work and deactivate their accounts.
DeviantArt’s DreamUp information page also takes a defensive tone, stating that DeviantArt did not consent to third-party AI image models (such as Stable Diffusion) that scraped their site to make their models work. And further down the page, the site attempts to debunk common misconceptions about how AI image synthesis works.
Link to the rest at Ars Technica
For those not familiar with DeviantArt, it’s an artists’ social network. It’s also a place for those who might might want to commission an artist to produce something like a cover design for a fantasy or science fiction novel.
PG’s understanding is that a great many artists who create images with computers/tablets+computers, etc., show some of their work in order to attract visitors to their websites. Of course, everything an artist puts up on Deviant Art is a digital image.
Based on the Ars Technica article, it sounds like DeviantArt really screwed up the launch of its AI Art tool.
One of the things a creator may find in the T’s&C’s is a provision that says the site owner can change the T’s&C’s at any time without notifying the creator in advance.
On our Products, you can send messages, take photos and videos, buy or sell things and much more. We call all of the things you can do on our Products “activity.” We collect your activity across our Products and information you provide, such as:
- Content you create, like posts, comments or audio
- Content you provide through our camera feature or your camera roll settings, or through our voice-enabled features. Learn more about what we collect from these features, and how we use information from the camera for masks, filters, avatars and effects.
- Messages you send and receive, including their content, subject to applicable law. We can’t see the content of end-to-end encrypted messages unless users report them to us for review. Learn more.
- Metadata about content and messages, subject to applicable law
- Types of content you view or interact with, and how you interact with it
- Apps and features you use, and what actions you take in them. See examples.
- Purchases or other transactions you make, including credit card information. Learn more.
- Hashtags you use
- The time, frequency and duration of your activities on our Products
Information with special protections
You might choose to provide information about your religious views, political views, who you are “interested in” (which could reveal your sexual orientation) or your health in your Facebook profile fields or life events. This and other information (such as racial or ethnic origin, philosophical beliefs or trade union membership) could have special protections under the laws of your country.
(PG Note: You have to click to a separate page to continue reading the Terms of Service)
(The Facebook Docs continue.)
Friends, followers and other connections
Information we collect about your friends, followers and other connections
We collect information about friends, followers, groups, accounts, Facebook Pages and other users and communities you’re connected to and interact with. This includes how you interact with them across our Products and which ones you interact with the most.
Information we collect about contacts
We also collect your contacts’ information, such as their name and email address or phone number, if you choose to upload or import it from a device, like by syncing an address book.
If you don’t use Meta Products, or use them without an account, your information might still be collected. Learn more about how Meta uses contact information uploaded by account holders.
App, browser and device information
We collect and receive information from and about the different devices you use and how you use them.
Device information we collect and receive includes:
- The device and software you’re using, and other device characteristics. See examples.
- What you’re doing on your device, like whether our app is in the foreground or if your mouse is moving (which can help tell humans from bots)
- Identifiers that tell your device apart from other users’, including Family Device IDs. See examples.
- Signals from your device. See examples.
- Information you’ve shared with us through device settings, like GPS location, camera access, photos and related metadata
- Information about the network you connect your device to, including your IP address. See more examples.
- Information about our Products’ performance on your device. Learn more.
- Information from cookies and similar technologies.
Information we collect or infer about you based on others’ activity
We collect information about you based on others’ activity. See some examples.
We also infer things about you based on others’ activity. For example:
- We may suggest a friend to you through Facebook’s People You May Know feature if you both appear on a contact list that someone uploads.
- We take into account whether your friends belong to a group when we suggest you join it.
Information from Partners, vendors and third parties
What kinds of information do we collect or receive?
Here are some examples of information we receive about you:
- Your device information
- Websites you visit and cookie data, like through Social Plugins or the Meta Pixel
- Apps you use
- Games you play
- Purchases and transactions you make
- Your demographics, like your education level
- The ads you see and how you interact with them
- How you use our Partners’ products and services, online or in person
Partners also share information like your email address, cookies and advertising device ID with us. This helps us match your activities with your account, if you have one.
We receive this information whether or not you’re logged in or have an account on our Products. Learn more about how we connect information from Partners to your account.
How do we collect or receive this information from partners?
Partners use our Business Tools, integrations and Meta Audience Network technologies to share information with us.
These Partners collect your information when you visit their site or app or use their services, or through other businesses or organizations they work with. We require Partners to have the right to collect, use and share your information before giving it to us.
Lawyer PG notes all the links to other places sprinkled through Facebook’s TOS. Each of the links includes yet more information that is part of the TOS. While PG didn’t click and read what was to be found in each of the links in the Mother TOS, PG will note that the links can include information and definitions that changes the meanings Mother TOS substantially.
PG doesn’t know whether Facebook’s Terms of Service as a whole are great, sorta-great, somewhere-in-the-middle, sorta terrible or terrible because he swore off of Facebook a long time ago. He has more than one Facebook account that contains information that has nothing to do with PG-in-the-flesh if he finds out about something Facebook is doing that may be of interest to PG or visitors to TPV.
PG hasn’t read Deviant Arts’ TOU, TOS, etc., but these are some of the concerns that artists who use Deviant Arts as a marketing platform are likely thinking about at the moment.
This will take PG awhile to finish, so don’t hold your breath waiting for it.